When citizen deliberation enters real politics: how politicians and stakeholders envision the place of a deliberative mini-public in political decision-making

Résultats de recherche: Contribution à un journal/une revueArticleRevue par des pairs

10 Téléchargements (Pure)

Résumé

In the wake of the increasing use of deliberative citizen assemblies in the public sphere, this article studies how traditional policy actors receive a mini-public as ‘newcomer’ in political decision-making, despite its reliance on a fundamentally different vision of policy-making and that it substantially alters existing power distributions. Survey data collected before and after a typical mini-public case, the Citizen Climate Parliament, shows that most politicians and stakeholders welcome this ‘newcomer’ as long as it remains consultative. A typological discourse analysis of 28 semi-structured interviews with these politicians and stakeholders suggests that this attitude comes with four different views of mini-publics’ place in political decision-making: an elitist-, expert-, (re)connection- and reinvention view. Given that an important correlate of these views was the extent to which actors agreed with the recommendations of the mini-public, it shows that their views were driven both by actors’ interests in the outcome on a micro-level and by their general ideas about political decision-making on a macro-level. The findings illustrate that mini-publics may encounter opposition from both political actors and stakeholders once they aim to take a place in political decision-making that goes beyond occasional and consultative uses. At the same time, these results show that the use of mini-publics does not leave traditional representative institutions unaffected as it prompts them to think about the place that citizen deliberation should take in the political system.

langue originaleAnglais
Pages (de - à)481-503
Nombre de pages23
journalPolicy Sciences
Volume52
Numéro de publication3
Les DOIs
Etat de la publicationPublié - 15 sept. 2019

mots-clés

  • deliberative system
  • mini-publics
  • elites
  • stakeholders
  • discourse analysis

Empreinte digitale

Examiner les sujets de recherche de « When citizen deliberation enters real politics: how politicians and stakeholders envision the place of a deliberative mini-public in political decision-making ». Ensemble, ils forment une empreinte digitale unique.

Contient cette citation