Two recent methods (Shanno, 1978; Toint, 1980) for revising estimates of sparse second derivative matrices in quasi-Newton optimization algorithms reduce to variable metric formulae when there are no sparsity conditions. It is proved that these methods are equivalent. Further, some examples are given to show that the procedure may make the second derivative approximations worse when the objective function is quadratic. Therefore the convergence properties of the procedure are sometimes less good than the convergence properties of other published methods for revising sparse second derivative approximations. © 1981, by Academic Press Inc. (London) Limited.