Abstract
Over the end of the last century, an increasing number of paleopathological reports pretend to present clues in favor of the existence of caring and “compassionate” behaviors toward disabled individuals in prehistoric human societies. Despite the arguments put forward by paleopathologists, this claim raises important questions, not only within the sciences of prehistory but also from the field of the disability studies wherein the notion of “compassion” has been extensively criticized. After a short introduction to paleopathology and to two case studies considered as major references in the scientific literature, this article outlines the main issues which are at stake in the debate that originates in conflicting interpretations with regard to empiric data in the paleopathological literature from 1970 to nowadays.
Original language | French |
---|---|
Pages (from-to) | 10–23 |
Journal | Alter : Revue européenne de recherche sur le handicap |
Volume | 10 |
Issue number | 1 |
DOIs | |
Publication status | Published - 2016 |
Keywords
- Prehistory
- Paleopathology
- Disability
- Compassion
- Care
- Critique
Student theses
-
Vulnérabilité, soin et handicap: Pourquoi les sociétés humaines prennent-elles soin de leurs membres infirmes, et pourquoi doivent-elles le faire?
Author: Doat, D., 20 Jan 2016Supervisor: Lambert, D. (Supervisor), Cobbaut, J. (External person) (Co-Supervisor), Palumbo, G. (President), Rizzerio, L. (Jury), Stiker, H. (External person) (Jury), Rezsöhazy, R. (External person) (Jury), Charmetant, E. (External person) (Jury) & Arènes, J. (External person) (Jury)
Student thesis: Doc types › Doctor of Philosophy
File