Factors Controlling Cage Escape Yields of Closed- and Open-Shell Metal Complexes in Bimolecular Photoinduced Electron Transfer

The cage escape yield, i.e., the separation of the geminate radical pair formed immediately after bimolecular excited-state electron transfer, was studied in 11 solvents using six Fe(III), Ru(II), and Ir(III) photosensitizers and tri-p-tolylamine as the electron donor. Among all complexes, the largest cage escape yields (0.67-1) were recorded for the Ir(III) photosensitizer, showing the highest potential as a photocatalyst in photoredox catalysis. These yields dropped to values around 0.65 for both Ru(II) photosensitizers and to values around 0.38 for the Os(II) photosensitizer. Interestingly, for both open-shell Fe(III) complexes, the yields were small (<0.1) in solvents with dielectric constant greater than 20 but were shown to reach values up to 0.58 in solvents with low dielectric constants. The results presented herein on closed-shell photosensitizers suggest that the low rate of triplet-singlet intersystem crossing within the manifold of states of the geminate radical pair implies that charge recombination toward the ground state is a spin-forbidden process, favoring large cage escape yields that are not influenced by dielectric effects. Geminate charge recombination in open-shell metal complexes, such as the two Fe(III) photosensitizers studied herein, is no longer a spin-forbidden process and becomes highly sensitive to solvent effects. Altogether, this study provides general guidelines for factors influencing bimolecular excited-state reactivity using prototypical photosensitizers but also allows one to foresee a great development of Fe(III) photosensitizers with the ²LMCT excited state in photoredox catalysis, providing that solvents with low dielectric constants are used.