Different response–effect trait relationships underlie contrasting responses to two chemical stressors

Christoph Mensens, Frederik De Laender, Colin R. Janssen, Koen Sabbe, Marleen De Troch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Trait-based approaches evaluate ecosystem functioning under environmental change by relating traits predicting changes in species densities (response traits) to traits driving ecosystem functioning (effect traits). Stressors can, however, affect ecosystem functioning not only by altering species densities but also by directly changing species effect traits. We first identified the response traits predicting the cell density of 18 marine benthic diatom strains along gradients of two chemical stressors (a pesticide and a metal, atrazine and copper). We then tested if response traits could predict stressor-induced changes in ecosystem functioning, i.e. changes in the effect traits driving the diatoms’ potential contribution to primary production, sediment stabilization and energy content in intertidal systems. Finally, we examined if changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were correlated, to assess whether species capable of growing under stressful conditions could maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. The relationship between response traits and stressor-induced changes in density and ecosystem functioning was different depending on stressor type: a set of intercorrelated morphological traits predicted changes in both density and ecosystem functioning under metal stress, with large cells being more stress resistant. Changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were positively related: diatoms whose density was least affected by the metal were also able to sustain functioning under metal exposure. In contrast, the capacity for mixotrophic growth predicted changes in density, but not changes in ecosystem functioning under pesticide stress. Pesticide effects on density and on ecosystem functioning were negatively related for energy content and sediment stabilization, indicating a limited capacity of pesticide-tolerant diatoms to maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. Synthesis. Ecosystem functioning under stress can depend on whether the response traits driving changes in species densities also predict direct stress effects on the species’ contribution to functioning. Based on our results, we expect a disproportionate loss of functioning when traits driving species densities do not allow to maintain ecosystem functioning under stress.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1598-1609
Number of pages12
JournalJournal of Ecology
Volume105
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2017

Fingerprint

ecosystems
ecosystem
Bacillariophyceae
diatom
pesticide
pesticides
metals
metal
chemical
energy content
stabilization
ecosystem approach
sediments
atrazine
sediment
energy
primary production
environmental change
primary productivity
effect

Keywords

  • algae
  • aquatic plant ecology
  • diatom
  • ecosystem function
  • effect trait
  • herbicide
  • marine
  • metal
  • response trait
  • stress

Cite this

Mensens, Christoph ; De Laender, Frederik ; Janssen, Colin R. ; Sabbe, Koen ; De Troch, Marleen. / Different response–effect trait relationships underlie contrasting responses to two chemical stressors. In: Journal of Ecology. 2017 ; Vol. 105, No. 6. pp. 1598-1609.
@article{7f8d797966414e0a98786829a5c273b6,
title = "Different response–effect trait relationships underlie contrasting responses to two chemical stressors",
abstract = "Trait-based approaches evaluate ecosystem functioning under environmental change by relating traits predicting changes in species densities (response traits) to traits driving ecosystem functioning (effect traits). Stressors can, however, affect ecosystem functioning not only by altering species densities but also by directly changing species effect traits. We first identified the response traits predicting the cell density of 18 marine benthic diatom strains along gradients of two chemical stressors (a pesticide and a metal, atrazine and copper). We then tested if response traits could predict stressor-induced changes in ecosystem functioning, i.e. changes in the effect traits driving the diatoms’ potential contribution to primary production, sediment stabilization and energy content in intertidal systems. Finally, we examined if changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were correlated, to assess whether species capable of growing under stressful conditions could maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. The relationship between response traits and stressor-induced changes in density and ecosystem functioning was different depending on stressor type: a set of intercorrelated morphological traits predicted changes in both density and ecosystem functioning under metal stress, with large cells being more stress resistant. Changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were positively related: diatoms whose density was least affected by the metal were also able to sustain functioning under metal exposure. In contrast, the capacity for mixotrophic growth predicted changes in density, but not changes in ecosystem functioning under pesticide stress. Pesticide effects on density and on ecosystem functioning were negatively related for energy content and sediment stabilization, indicating a limited capacity of pesticide-tolerant diatoms to maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. Synthesis. Ecosystem functioning under stress can depend on whether the response traits driving changes in species densities also predict direct stress effects on the species’ contribution to functioning. Based on our results, we expect a disproportionate loss of functioning when traits driving species densities do not allow to maintain ecosystem functioning under stress.",
keywords = "algae, aquatic plant ecology, diatom, ecosystem function, effect trait, herbicide, marine, metal, response trait, stress",
author = "Christoph Mensens and {De Laender}, Frederik and Janssen, {Colin R.} and Koen Sabbe and {De Troch}, Marleen",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/1365-2745.12777",
language = "English",
volume = "105",
pages = "1598--1609",
journal = "Journal of Ecology",
issn = "0022-0477",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell Publishing",
number = "6",

}

Different response–effect trait relationships underlie contrasting responses to two chemical stressors. / Mensens, Christoph; De Laender, Frederik; Janssen, Colin R.; Sabbe, Koen; De Troch, Marleen.

In: Journal of Ecology, Vol. 105, No. 6, 01.11.2017, p. 1598-1609.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Different response–effect trait relationships underlie contrasting responses to two chemical stressors

AU - Mensens, Christoph

AU - De Laender, Frederik

AU - Janssen, Colin R.

AU - Sabbe, Koen

AU - De Troch, Marleen

PY - 2017/11/1

Y1 - 2017/11/1

N2 - Trait-based approaches evaluate ecosystem functioning under environmental change by relating traits predicting changes in species densities (response traits) to traits driving ecosystem functioning (effect traits). Stressors can, however, affect ecosystem functioning not only by altering species densities but also by directly changing species effect traits. We first identified the response traits predicting the cell density of 18 marine benthic diatom strains along gradients of two chemical stressors (a pesticide and a metal, atrazine and copper). We then tested if response traits could predict stressor-induced changes in ecosystem functioning, i.e. changes in the effect traits driving the diatoms’ potential contribution to primary production, sediment stabilization and energy content in intertidal systems. Finally, we examined if changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were correlated, to assess whether species capable of growing under stressful conditions could maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. The relationship between response traits and stressor-induced changes in density and ecosystem functioning was different depending on stressor type: a set of intercorrelated morphological traits predicted changes in both density and ecosystem functioning under metal stress, with large cells being more stress resistant. Changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were positively related: diatoms whose density was least affected by the metal were also able to sustain functioning under metal exposure. In contrast, the capacity for mixotrophic growth predicted changes in density, but not changes in ecosystem functioning under pesticide stress. Pesticide effects on density and on ecosystem functioning were negatively related for energy content and sediment stabilization, indicating a limited capacity of pesticide-tolerant diatoms to maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. Synthesis. Ecosystem functioning under stress can depend on whether the response traits driving changes in species densities also predict direct stress effects on the species’ contribution to functioning. Based on our results, we expect a disproportionate loss of functioning when traits driving species densities do not allow to maintain ecosystem functioning under stress.

AB - Trait-based approaches evaluate ecosystem functioning under environmental change by relating traits predicting changes in species densities (response traits) to traits driving ecosystem functioning (effect traits). Stressors can, however, affect ecosystem functioning not only by altering species densities but also by directly changing species effect traits. We first identified the response traits predicting the cell density of 18 marine benthic diatom strains along gradients of two chemical stressors (a pesticide and a metal, atrazine and copper). We then tested if response traits could predict stressor-induced changes in ecosystem functioning, i.e. changes in the effect traits driving the diatoms’ potential contribution to primary production, sediment stabilization and energy content in intertidal systems. Finally, we examined if changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were correlated, to assess whether species capable of growing under stressful conditions could maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. The relationship between response traits and stressor-induced changes in density and ecosystem functioning was different depending on stressor type: a set of intercorrelated morphological traits predicted changes in both density and ecosystem functioning under metal stress, with large cells being more stress resistant. Changes in density and changes in ecosystem functioning were positively related: diatoms whose density was least affected by the metal were also able to sustain functioning under metal exposure. In contrast, the capacity for mixotrophic growth predicted changes in density, but not changes in ecosystem functioning under pesticide stress. Pesticide effects on density and on ecosystem functioning were negatively related for energy content and sediment stabilization, indicating a limited capacity of pesticide-tolerant diatoms to maintain their contribution to ecosystem functioning. Synthesis. Ecosystem functioning under stress can depend on whether the response traits driving changes in species densities also predict direct stress effects on the species’ contribution to functioning. Based on our results, we expect a disproportionate loss of functioning when traits driving species densities do not allow to maintain ecosystem functioning under stress.

KW - algae

KW - aquatic plant ecology

KW - diatom

KW - ecosystem function

KW - effect trait

KW - herbicide

KW - marine

KW - metal

KW - response trait

KW - stress

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85018252334&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1365-2745.12777

DO - 10.1111/1365-2745.12777

M3 - Article

VL - 105

SP - 1598

EP - 1609

JO - Journal of Ecology

JF - Journal of Ecology

SN - 0022-0477

IS - 6

ER -