Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements: a case from the Lower Cretaceous plant assemblage of Hautrage (Mons Basin, Belgium)

Abel Barral, Bernard Gomez, Juan M. Zorrilla, José M. Serrano, Johan Yans, Véronique Daviero-Gomez, Timothy A M Ewin, Christophe Lécuyer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Two plant fossil-bearing beds from the middle Barremian of Belgium were analysed to ascertain how experimental designs affect conclusions regarding palaeodiversity at a local scale. We analysed eight lateral samples per bed taken regularly every 3 m using an exhaustive sub-sampling method. The Clench equation was used to evaluate the completeness of the taxonomic inventory of the samples and the sampling effort needed to obtain a reliable representation of diversity. The number of replicates needed to obtain the same representation of diversity from different nearby lateral samples of the same bed ranged from 5 to 19. Richness (S), Evenness (J) and the number of equiprobable taxa (2H’) greatly varied between samples from the same bed, even over short distances. Only one of the studied samples was representative of the taxonomic inventory of its bed. Our study shows that 1) the selection bias of the sampling area is reduced by increasing the number of lateral samples taken in a bed, enabling more reliable conclusions about local-scale diversity; 2) intense sub-sampling methods are needed to account for statistically independent observations of detailed lateral variation; and 3) sampling methods in palaeodiversity analyses must look for a similar degree of representativeness in samples rather than a homogeneous sample size. Using a sampling effort analysis provides evidence for the completeness of the data set, adjusting the amount of work required. Implementing the Clench equation in palaeodiversity analyses improves the performance of data acquisition in palaeoecological studies and provides a quality test of the data sets derived from them.

LanguageEnglish
Pages244-257
Number of pages14
JournalLethaia
Volume50
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 Apr 2017

Fingerprint

Belgium
basins
Cretaceous
sampling
basin
Barremian
data acquisition
experimental design
fossil
method
fossils
methodology

Keywords

  • Barremian
  • Clench equation
  • diversity
  • lateral sampling
  • palaeoecology
  • sampling effort

Cite this

Barral, Abel ; Gomez, Bernard ; Zorrilla, Juan M. ; Serrano, José M. ; Yans, Johan ; Daviero-Gomez, Véronique ; Ewin, Timothy A M ; Lécuyer, Christophe. / Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements : a case from the Lower Cretaceous plant assemblage of Hautrage (Mons Basin, Belgium). In: Lethaia. 2017 ; Vol. 50, No. 2. pp. 244-257
@article{1e748622674a4264acaec157bdfd1d42,
title = "Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements: a case from the Lower Cretaceous plant assemblage of Hautrage (Mons Basin, Belgium)",
abstract = "Two plant fossil-bearing beds from the middle Barremian of Belgium were analysed to ascertain how experimental designs affect conclusions regarding palaeodiversity at a local scale. We analysed eight lateral samples per bed taken regularly every 3 m using an exhaustive sub-sampling method. The Clench equation was used to evaluate the completeness of the taxonomic inventory of the samples and the sampling effort needed to obtain a reliable representation of diversity. The number of replicates needed to obtain the same representation of diversity from different nearby lateral samples of the same bed ranged from 5 to 19. Richness (S), Evenness (J) and the number of equiprobable taxa (2H’) greatly varied between samples from the same bed, even over short distances. Only one of the studied samples was representative of the taxonomic inventory of its bed. Our study shows that 1) the selection bias of the sampling area is reduced by increasing the number of lateral samples taken in a bed, enabling more reliable conclusions about local-scale diversity; 2) intense sub-sampling methods are needed to account for statistically independent observations of detailed lateral variation; and 3) sampling methods in palaeodiversity analyses must look for a similar degree of representativeness in samples rather than a homogeneous sample size. Using a sampling effort analysis provides evidence for the completeness of the data set, adjusting the amount of work required. Implementing the Clench equation in palaeodiversity analyses improves the performance of data acquisition in palaeoecological studies and provides a quality test of the data sets derived from them.",
keywords = "Barremian, Clench equation, diversity, lateral sampling, palaeoecology, sampling effort",
author = "Abel Barral and Bernard Gomez and Zorrilla, {Juan M.} and Serrano, {Jos{\'e} M.} and Johan Yans and V{\'e}ronique Daviero-Gomez and Ewin, {Timothy A M} and Christophe L{\'e}cuyer",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/let.12194",
language = "English",
volume = "50",
pages = "244--257",
journal = "Lethaia",
issn = "0024-1164",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

Barral, A, Gomez, B, Zorrilla, JM, Serrano, JM, Yans, J, Daviero-Gomez, V, Ewin, TAM & Lécuyer, C 2017, 'Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements: a case from the Lower Cretaceous plant assemblage of Hautrage (Mons Basin, Belgium)' Lethaia, vol. 50, no. 2, pp. 244-257. DOI: 10.1111/let.12194

Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements : a case from the Lower Cretaceous plant assemblage of Hautrage (Mons Basin, Belgium). / Barral, Abel; Gomez, Bernard; Zorrilla, Juan M.; Serrano, José M.; Yans, Johan; Daviero-Gomez, Véronique; Ewin, Timothy A M; Lécuyer, Christophe.

In: Lethaia, Vol. 50, No. 2, 01.04.2017, p. 244-257.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Analysing the representativeness of local-scale palaeodiversity measurements

T2 - Lethaia

AU - Barral,Abel

AU - Gomez,Bernard

AU - Zorrilla,Juan M.

AU - Serrano,José M.

AU - Yans,Johan

AU - Daviero-Gomez,Véronique

AU - Ewin,Timothy A M

AU - Lécuyer,Christophe

PY - 2017/4/1

Y1 - 2017/4/1

N2 - Two plant fossil-bearing beds from the middle Barremian of Belgium were analysed to ascertain how experimental designs affect conclusions regarding palaeodiversity at a local scale. We analysed eight lateral samples per bed taken regularly every 3 m using an exhaustive sub-sampling method. The Clench equation was used to evaluate the completeness of the taxonomic inventory of the samples and the sampling effort needed to obtain a reliable representation of diversity. The number of replicates needed to obtain the same representation of diversity from different nearby lateral samples of the same bed ranged from 5 to 19. Richness (S), Evenness (J) and the number of equiprobable taxa (2H’) greatly varied between samples from the same bed, even over short distances. Only one of the studied samples was representative of the taxonomic inventory of its bed. Our study shows that 1) the selection bias of the sampling area is reduced by increasing the number of lateral samples taken in a bed, enabling more reliable conclusions about local-scale diversity; 2) intense sub-sampling methods are needed to account for statistically independent observations of detailed lateral variation; and 3) sampling methods in palaeodiversity analyses must look for a similar degree of representativeness in samples rather than a homogeneous sample size. Using a sampling effort analysis provides evidence for the completeness of the data set, adjusting the amount of work required. Implementing the Clench equation in palaeodiversity analyses improves the performance of data acquisition in palaeoecological studies and provides a quality test of the data sets derived from them.

AB - Two plant fossil-bearing beds from the middle Barremian of Belgium were analysed to ascertain how experimental designs affect conclusions regarding palaeodiversity at a local scale. We analysed eight lateral samples per bed taken regularly every 3 m using an exhaustive sub-sampling method. The Clench equation was used to evaluate the completeness of the taxonomic inventory of the samples and the sampling effort needed to obtain a reliable representation of diversity. The number of replicates needed to obtain the same representation of diversity from different nearby lateral samples of the same bed ranged from 5 to 19. Richness (S), Evenness (J) and the number of equiprobable taxa (2H’) greatly varied between samples from the same bed, even over short distances. Only one of the studied samples was representative of the taxonomic inventory of its bed. Our study shows that 1) the selection bias of the sampling area is reduced by increasing the number of lateral samples taken in a bed, enabling more reliable conclusions about local-scale diversity; 2) intense sub-sampling methods are needed to account for statistically independent observations of detailed lateral variation; and 3) sampling methods in palaeodiversity analyses must look for a similar degree of representativeness in samples rather than a homogeneous sample size. Using a sampling effort analysis provides evidence for the completeness of the data set, adjusting the amount of work required. Implementing the Clench equation in palaeodiversity analyses improves the performance of data acquisition in palaeoecological studies and provides a quality test of the data sets derived from them.

KW - Barremian

KW - Clench equation

KW - diversity

KW - lateral sampling

KW - palaeoecology

KW - sampling effort

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84998865181&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/let.12194

DO - 10.1111/let.12194

M3 - Article

VL - 50

SP - 244

EP - 257

JO - Lethaia

JF - Lethaia

SN - 0024-1164

IS - 2

ER -